Film Review: Voice from the Stone, Frequently Frustrating

Photograph courtesy of Momentum Pictures

This odd but sometimes captivating bit of Gothic psychological drama with a hint of a ghost story sprinkled in for added flavor is sneaking out into the world this week courtesy of director (and former stunt coordinator) Eric D. Howell (From Heaven to Hell). Based on the Italian novel by Silvio Raffo (and adapted by Andrew Shaw), Voice from the Stone is the story of Verena (Emilia Clarke, of “Game of Thrones” and Me Before You), a young British woman living in Italy, circa the 1950s, where she seems to specialize in being a private nurse for the sick children of rich families. But the curse of her job is that once the child is better, the families dismiss her, wanting no memory of the terrible sickness (be it physical ailment or mental dismay).

Verena is summoned to Tuscany to care for young Jakob (Edward Dring), who hasn’t spoken a word since his mother, a famous classical piano player (Caterina Murino) died after a terrible illness. His father, Klaus (Marton Csokas), a sculptor, is also distraught to the point where he doesn’t believe he can take care of Jakob by himself. After Verena moves he, she begins to notice that Jakob isn’t just silent; he’s also behaving strangely, often pushing his ear to the walls of the house, where it seems he can hear his dead mother’s voice speaking to him from the stones taken from the nearby family-owned but long closed quarry, one of Jakob’s favorite spots.

Without many sane specimens in the house, Verena befriends an elderly woman named Lilia (the great Lisa Gastoni), but even that friendship is wrought with complications. Voice from the Stone is dripping with creepy atmosphere and eerie locations that seem custom made for a horror film made 50 years ago. Cinematographer Peter Simonite deserves points for shooting the home, in particular, like it would be the kind of place where a ghost might live in the walls. There’s also a family crypt nearby that is downright terrifying.

The problem is that the movie feels like third-rate Jane Eyre, as it allows the low rumbles of romance between Verena and Klaus take over the far more interesting story of what is going on with Jakob and whether a dead woman is speaking to him and perhaps others in the house. Voice from the Stone is frequently frustrating because it has so much going for it that it doesn’t capitalize upon. And while I certainly applaud the idea of these two lonely people finding something comforting in each other, the film’s strange and nebulous ending blurs the ultimate meaning of the entire work and even has us questioning the identity of certain characters. It’s a close call, and ultimately Clarke’s thoughtful performance makes this an easy watch, even if the plot is often tiresome.

Unfortunately, the film is not currently opening theatrically in Chicago. With that said, it is available on Amazon and other VOD platforms beginning today.

Steve Prokopy
Steve Prokopy

Steve Prokopy is chief film critic for the Chicago-based arts outlet
Third Coast Review. For nearly 20 years, he was the Chicago editor for
Ain’t It Cool News, where he contributed film reviews and
filmmaker/actor interviews under the name “Capone.” Currently, he’s a
frequent contributor at /Film ( and Backstory Magazine.
He is also the public relations director for Chicago's independently
owned Music Box Theatre, and holds the position of Vice President for
the Chicago Film Critics Association. In addition, he is a programmer
for the Chicago Critics Film Festival, which has been one of the
city's most anticipated festivals since 2013.


  1. About Voice Frim the Stone…
    I agree with the world…mostly because I honestly believe I am “mass man”. If I like it everyone wiil.

    The movie had it all going for it. Artists, sex, mystery, landscaping extradoinare, location, secrets, a damaged child , and I likes the Director. What was missing was the 2nd story… you know… the story behind the story.
    like when a character does something we knew she had to do because her pain was so deep she couldnt get over it.
    Why the nurse maid did what she did/does…was simply missing.
    Was she an ancient person who had lives multiple lives and no longer cared about much, but at the same time, knew how to do a great job at what she did?
    Did she go from being one person to another person…and the original talented psychiatrist person was delited, erased – when her body was taken over by the deceased mother?
    Somehow the ghost ofvthevdeceased mother was deleated, and the boy gets well (from communication with a healer – of sorts) so the psychiatrist governess leaves, after having a hot affair with the lonely husband?
    Seriously… where/ what is the story line?
    It just didn’t show me the why..the how..of this female character.
    Was she a nun?
    If so… now that would of , at the very least, … made sense.
    The healer was already married… to Christ !

    Just by defining who the female character actually was, ….well, that could have been a 2nd runner up to The Exorcist.

    So…I am left with, “Who was this woman?”
    I must say that even the infamous character, Rebecca, who we all wonder about, was at its base about women who did not have legal right to own land by themselves, and were forced to marry, to own a piece of property.
    But I dont know what the core is of the Stone woman…indeed…. I still dont know !
    I will always wonder who she really was.
    Maybe that was the goal… the constant wondering.

Comments are closed.

Plan Your Life with 3CR Highlights

Join Our Newsletter today!