The Nance Teaches Us Some History in the Midst of Burlesque Routines

Sivertsen and Kracht on stage at the Irving Place. Photo by Paul Goyette. The play opens with a bubbly Sylvie (Melissa Young) singing and dancing to “I Wish I Could Shimmy Like My Sister Kate” on the stage of an old New York burlesque theater. That number sets the time (1937) and the scene for The Nance, which is both an uproariously silly set of burlesque acts, antique in their humor, and historic reminders of how we got to where we are today in terms of sexual repression and artistic censorship. Douglas Carter Beane’s play, now on stage at Pride Films and Plays, is the story of Chauncey Miles (Vince Kracht), a gay man who plays an effeminate man on stage (the “nance act”), which was acceptable in the 1930s, while actual homosexual behavior was outlawed. (It remained illegal here until 1962, when Illinois repealed its sodomy law, and during the 1970s and later in other states.* Some states still criminalize homosexual acts.) Once the nance act becomes risky because of the attention of the city’s licensing commissioner, there is another way for Chauncey to perform, as one of his colleagues says. “Oh, but get this - he can do a drag bit. ‘ Cause drag ain't deviant, it's ‘masquerade.’” (Both Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia and license commissioner Paul Moss get shout-outs in The Nance. LaGuardia shut down the burlesque houses for a brief time in 1937, upon Moss’ recommendation. And the dancers report that Helen Hayes speaks against censorship at a protest rally.) The Nance ensemble. Photo by Paul Goyette. The burlesque acts at the Irving Place Theatre make up almost half of The Nance, which is riproaringly directed by John Nasca. You’ll see a feathery fan dance by Joan (Britt-Marie Sivertsen) and other songs, dances and modest strip routines by Sylvie and Carmen (Steph Vondell). The women’s costumes are colorful and sparkly—and designed by Nasca, doing double duty as costume designer. Efram (Patrick Rybarczyk) is the First Banana of the burlesque show. He and Chauncey riff off of each other in the comedy numbers that bracket the dance acts. The play’s story line is about Chauncey’s career problems plus his romantic relationship with young Ned (charmingly played by Royen Kent), who becomes a performer at the Irving Place as well as Chauncey’s soulmate. A few scenes are played at a Greenwich Village Horn & Hardart’s Automat, which was notorious as a place where men could (cautiously) meet other men. Nasca’s direction keeps things moving briskly; the 2.5 hour play rarely drags. Scenic design by Jeremy Hollis outfits Pride’s stage as the theater and Chauncey’s apartment with the movement of a few furniture pieces and a projection screen above the stage, which identifies the location or the song being performed by the burlesque cast. Live music, directed by Robert Ollis, enhances the burlesque mood. The Nance by Pride Films & Plays continues at the Pride Arts Center, 4139 N. Broadway, through August 13. Tickets are $30-40 for performances Thursday-Sunday. Or call 800-737-0984 for tickets and info.

  *   *   *

Note. Same-sex activity became legal in Illinois in 1962, Connecticut in 1971, Colorado and Oregon in 1972, Delaware and Hawaii in 1973, Massachusetts and Ohio in 1974, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Dakota in 1975, California, Maine, Washington, and West Virginia in 1976, Indiana, Iowa, South Dakota, Vermont, and Wyoming in 1977, Nebraska in 1978, New Jersey in 1979, Alaska, New York, and Pennsylvania in 1980, Wisconsin in 1983, Kentucky in 1992, Nevada and District of Columbia in 1993, Tennessee in 1996, Montana in 1997, Georgia and Rhode Island in 1998, Maryland and Missouri (Western District counties only) in 1999, Arizona and Minnesota in 2001, and Arkansas in 2002.
Picture of the author
Nancy S Bishop

Nancy S. Bishop is publisher and Stages editor of Third Coast Review. She’s a member of the American Theatre Critics Association and a 2014 Fellow of the National Critics Institute at the Eugene O’Neill Theater Center. You can read her personal writing on pop culture at, and follow her on Twitter @nsbishop. She also writes about film, books, art, architecture and design.