New York Review: Irish Rep Explores Ireland in Civil War With The Shadow of a Gunman
Third Coast Review’s chief theater critic is spending the month of March in New York. This is is the first of her dispatches on New York theater and other arts.
It’s May 1920 in a Dublin tenement. The Irish War of Independence rages outside. But in this cluttered room, there’s a poet who may be a gunman. That’s Donal Davoren (James Russell), who shares the room with Seamus Shields (Michael Mellamphy), a traveling salesman of braces, laces, thread, spoons, forks, bits and bobs. Their relationship and their visits from neighbors play out against the backdrop of the guerrilla war against British rule.
Sean O’Casey’s play, The Shadow of a Gunman, now on stage at Irish Repertory Theatre, tricks us into thinking this might be a comedy about drunken and verbose Irishmen. It all takes place in one room, where a few comic or even buffoonish characters visit and dominate act one, before the play descends into reality. Director Ciaran O’Reilly, Irish Rep’s co-founder, threads these pieces together to create a faithful reproduction of O’Casey’s work, not a reinvention.
Mr. Maguire (Rory Duffy), known as a soldier of the IRA, stops in to see Seamus but quickly departs, leaving a sturdy black valise behind; he’ll retrieve it this evening, he says.
Little Tommy Owens (a rather tall Ed Malone) gabs officiously and doesn’t know when to leave. He’s joined by Mrs. Henderson (Una Clancy), with Mr. Gallagher (Robert Langdon Lloyd), who orates a goofily legalistic letter complaining about noisy neighbors and asking the IRA to send in their soldiers; he’s sure Donal can deliver it to the IRA. The romantic wannabe poet, Donal, seems amused that his neighbors, including the adorable Minnie Powell (Meg Hennessy), think he’s an IRA gunman. He doesn’t try to disabuse them of that. After a sweet scene with Minnie at the end of act one, Donal muses, “A gunman on the run? Be careful, Donal Davoren. But Minnie is attracted to the idea, and I am attracted to Minnie. And what danger can there be in being the shadow of a gunman?”
But it’s not far into act two when it’s clear that O’Casey is serious about Ireland’s fight for independence and what it means to live in fear of the Black and Tans. This is the time when British troops, both the British Army and the Royal Irish Constabulary along with other recruits (aka the Black and Tans) prowled the streets of Dublin, breaking in to search homes for guns, bombs and revolutionaries. The characters in The Shadow of a Gunman are all tired of the fighting. More than one of them says, “I wish the whole thing was over with.”
When Seamus awakes to hear tapping on the walls, he says “a quiet, steady mysterious tapping…. It’s a sure sign of death when nobody hears it but meself.”
And of course, Maguire’s valise turns out to be Chekhov’s gun. When the Tans begin knocking on doors, Minnie bravely takes it to her room, saying, “They won’t harm a girl.” When Minnie is taken away by the Tans, both Seamus and Donal worry about whether she’ll betray them, not about whether she will be harmed.
At the end, Seamus says, “ I knew something ud come of the tappin’ on the wall.”
O’Reilly’s direction keeps the action moving smoothly and this, the briefest of O’Casey’s trilogy, zips along in 90 minutes, plus an intermission. The cast is very solid, with fine performances from Mellamphy and Hennessy. The role of Donal is regularly performed by James Russell, but it was capably played by Adam Petherbridge when I saw the play.
Charlie Corcoran’s scenic design creates the proper mood with lighting by Michael Gottlieb. Ryan Rumery’s original music and sound design by Rumery and M. Florian Staab make the sounds of bombs and gunfire all too familiar. Costumes are by Linda Fisher and David Toser.
Sean O’Casey, considered one of Ireland’s finest playwrights, was born in the Dublin slums and was involved in the Irish Nationalist cause for years. His Dublin trilogy, now being staged as the O’Casey Cycle, focuses on the Irish Civil War and its impact on the Irish people. The Shadow of a Gunman will be followed by June and the Paycock, opening March 9 (watch for my review), and The Plough and the Stars, set at the time of the Easter Rising in 1916, on April 20. The O’Casey Cycle also includes free readings, lectures and film screenings. More info here.
The three plays in the O’Casey Cycle have been extended through June 22 at Irish Repertory Theatre, 132 W. 22nd St., New York. Buy tickets here.
Did you enjoy this review of off-Broadway theater? Please consider supporting Third Coast Review’s arts and culture coverage by becoming a patron. Choose the amount that works best for you, and know how much we appreciate your support!