Review: Without a Why, The Song of Names Lacks a Reason to Be a Film At All
The biggest problem with The Song of Names, in a film with many of them, is that it lacks a driving why behind any of the proceedings, anything to signal to an audience why on earth we should care about what’s unfolding on screen. Based on a novel by Norman Lebrecht, François Girard directs this overly wrought, listless drama (adapted by Jeffrey Caine) about a grown man seeking the Polish Jewish violinist who lived with his family in London during World War II only to disappear on the night of a post-war concert to showcase his talent.
Though the film is told mostly in flashbacks, Tim Roth and Clive Owen—two actors who deliver reliably strong performances despite the material they’re working with—play the grown men, Martin and Dovidl respectively, in the mid-’80s of the film’s present day. As World War II gets underway decades earlier, young Dovidl (Luke Doyle) auditions for young Martin’s (Misha Handley) father, who decides the boy has enough talent to warrant adopting him into their family in the face of growing anti-Semitism in his native Poland. Martin is having none of it, and is an unbearable brat to the young musician until, at some point he’s not and they’re friends as teenagers, even brothers (played by Gerran Howell and Jonah Hauer-King for this phase).
After Dovidl’s inexplicable no-show at a much-touted concert in 1951, Martin is left with nothing more than a name and memory of the person who once met so much to him. Thirty-five years later, while judging a local music competition, one of the student’s gestures before playing reminds him of his old friend and sends him on a path to track down the man who fell off the radar. What we come to learn is that Dovidl returned to the faith he was raised with, deeply damaged by the loss of family and community during the Holocaust. It all culminates in a full-circle moment that the film hasn’t earned in any way at all. We’re meant to believe that Martin is obsessed with finding Dovidl and Dovidl is obsessed with not being found, but there’s never a chance to understand why that would be the case for either. The narrative takes a particularly melancholy turn as it traces Dovidl’s life after the war, and though the film’s titular scene, where a rabbi sings out the names of those in Dovidl’s family who died at the hands of the Nazis, elicits sympathy, it never delivers the significant impact for which it aims. We’ve never met these people, we know nothing of the connection between Dovidl and any of them other than that they’re related.
In the end, though the novel about these men who were once so close and now navigate their path back to each other may be a page-turner, the film is anything but. More powerful, more meaningful and much better written stories of this era exist and are far more worth your time.
Did you enjoy this post? Please consider supporting Third Coast Review’s arts and culture coverage by becoming a patron. Choose the amount that works best for you, and know how much we appreciate your support!
Totally agree! It was a beautiful film and left me thinking about it for several days.
Incredible story which will I think remain with me. How many nation people have been displaced in history experiencing mass cruelty at the hands of a ruling class. The story should resonate with us all especially when everyday we hear about people fleeing from such regimes. I think the story was told incredibly well. We all need to stop and think.
If you don’t feel sorry about a family and children killed by nazis then you’re a snob. Families with little children, no matter the ethnicity or religion, do you understand that? I doubt it. The movie has great acting and the music is excellent, just be prepared for some sad moments if you aren’t like this “reviewer”.
Great movie. Don’t pay attention to bad reviews
I agree, it’s a beautiful and subtle film !
There was no big box office emotional sentimentality……… and a better film for it .
I completely agree with you. As I write this comment, I am listening to the score from this brilliant film. I absolutely loved it and felt deeply what each was feeling at every phase of life. When the rabi sang that song, it was like a dagger to my heart. I felt every loss of precious life. Watching Dovidl’s face was so painful.
Many people read reviews prior to viewing a film and I think its a mistake. Especially in this case. I recommend this film. Watch and feel and experience everything said and unsaid. It will stay with me for a long time to come.
A deeply moving film. Some of the scenes indelibly marked in my memory. Beautiful music, good acting and sets. I think Lisa the critic was a bit harsh how could the film be anything but melancholic it wasn’t a happy time. Ignore her watch the film
The reviewer lacks insight into the themes of this film: love, loss, friendship, and how we find peace. I found it subtle and beautiful. Well worth watching.
I can’t make a comment without a “spoiler alert” but it is a good source of deep discussion.
I think it was a beautiful movie. There are sweet delicate moments that you see when you pay attention to detail. Great movie. I am going to read more of his books that it was adapted from.
Comments are closed.