Graeters may be a midwest company that began in Ohio, but the French pot style ice cream has allowed them to spread across the midwest and beyond. With a focus on high fat and no air and a promise that this will be the best ice cream you will ever eat, I had to give it a try. If I’m going to claim expert on anything, I’m pretty sure ice cream is my best opportunity.
If I am turning to grocery store ice cream, your national level brands per se, I only buy Ben & Jerry’s. Not only because Cherry Garcia is the best thing to ever happen to frozen milk and that they commit to not only providing crunchy bits alongside the creamy, but because I know I am supporting a brand that ideologically and socially supports the things I care about. It’s a win-win purchase. To betray this long developed bond felt mildly icky, but sometimes you have to expand your horizons even if purely for research.
The seasonal flavors this holiday are eggnog and peppermint stick. The eggnog is not just a spiced-up vanilla. It’s extremely creamy and indulgent with the added kick in flavor thanks to your favorite boozy holiday drink. A scoop on its own feels a little heavy, but add a shot of espresso and it’s honestly the perfect holiday treat.
The peppermint stick lives up to its name. Filled with crunchy peppermint bites, it’s refreshing even while it packs the hefty creamy punch that the French pot process allows. Graeter’s has a whoopie pie made with a chocolate cookie and a scoop of peppermint smooshed in between and this honestly may be the way to go. To get the same effect, bake a pan of brownies and add a scoop on top. You’re welcome.
The fall flavors (pumpkin and cinnamon) sold out quickly at the shops near Chicago, so I would recommend getting your fix as soon as possible to take advantage of the holiday flavors. Graeter’s means it when they say limited time. Whether you pick up a pint at a local grocery store (I couldn’t find the holiday flavor pints at the Jewel or Mariano’s near me) or stop into one of the nearby scoop shops (closest are Winnetka and Northbrook), Graeter’s has select holiday flavors available as well as the staples, like birthday cake, salted caramel and more.
Now through December 31, Third Coast Review is raising money to support the diverse roster of writers you know and appreciate for their thoughtful, insightful arts and culture coverage in Chicago and beyond. Everything raised during this time will go directly to paying these writers a well-deserved year-end stipend; you can make a contribution here. Thank you!